Some things that bug me about the current comment system:

• I don't know when someone replies to my comment


• It's impossible to read them chronologically (not only is it ordered the wrong way, I have to read down to up, then scroll down, go to the next page, rinse, repeat).


• Quoting someone might be nice


• (maybe a bit too far out) liking comments and or mentioning people would improve discussion, but then again I just like the whole social/interaction/discussion part of the site. Might be a bit too much of a sidetrack of the site's goals.

As of now, "Remove from Watchlist" has to be clicked separately, in addition to checking it

Basically if you are working on two lists. You'll want finish checking movies that are on both list. So by being able to filter, let says the 501 Must See Movies with the IMDb 250, You'll be able to find out what movie you'll need to progress on the list at the same speed.

Your To-Watch list could be imported into your Netflix queue and Amazon watchlist, then all you'd have to do on those sites is put them in the order you want to see them. Right now I manage my film lists on multiple sites and it would save me time.

There are a lot of films you're likely to watch more than once. If it were possible to tick a film again when you've re-watched it, it would help users to keep track of what they've watched and when. It would also allow friends to see all that you've been watching - not just newly ticked films.

Import watched movies file .xml from site like www.listal.com

These features may be very server intensive, but anyways, here are some examples:

• of Checks per week/month




• of Checks per decade or year (in a graph or in some other way)



• A top 3 of the lists the user has been most actively checking movies from over the past months.

I don't know much about how the neighbours system works, but maybe more weight should be given to a movie which two members have favorited, but very few other people have favorited. This way members who both like a certain type of obscure movie type can more easily find eachother.

The search needs to be smarter and prioritized. Example: If you search "Secret of My Success", the Michael J. Fox movie is not returned because one of the S's is a dollar sign. With only one character off, the algorithm should return the movie as a result.

It does not work well.
Try searching for "Ong-bak" and you will get zero quick suggestions. Try searching for "ong bak" and you'll get "Ong-bak (2003)" as suggestion #1 and "Bus Stop (1956)" as suggestion #2.
Needs fixing!

Hello! I really like icheckmovies but the new version hasn't got one awesome feature of the previous one. When I open inbox messages about top lists update there are little icons "checked" or "unchecked" on the left of the movie title. Very convenient! It would be great to have the same feature in new version. Thank you!

Shorten down the All-Time Worldwide Box office list to 100o or 200. It's on 621 now and the list will only be increasing. Or just dump the list, it doesn't seem to be one of the best ones. Or just take the highest grossing movies from each year etc. Or something similar. Look in the comments of it to see that a lot of people seem to think similar to me.

trakt.tv could handle 'what did I already see' and ICM could focus on adding value through its lists.

Some lists contain lost movies and can never be completed (Platinum award). These lost movies should stay in the list (e.g. with a red cross icon), but a user will not be able to check them. So the list can be completed and a user is awarded.

Currently you can order lists by number of favorites, but not the ratio of favorites, which is a far better indicator of movie quality.

...so that i can see at one glance which links are still working and which aren't